The Malls Have Eyes…

The Malls Have Eyes

In a Marketing Consigliere blog from last year, it was noted that the integration of eye analytics and ultrasound by companies such as Influence Media make possible the delivery of audio messages to precise spots in a public space, based on eye contact .  Another blog from around the same time described the possibility of using video and off-the-shelf technologies to profile automobiles entering a parking lot and target messages via digital signage as shoppers enter stores.

Now, a year later, a recent wire by AP’s Dinesh Ramde that was run in a multitude of publications documents another stage in the evolution of net-centric marketing in a retail environment.  The headlines ran “When you’re watching an ad, it might also be watching you,” or “…checking you out.”

This may be rather alarmist, but the truth is that the B2C advertising world is trying to get more personal – literally.  TrueMedia Technologies, Inc. is one of the companies mentioned in the article that is leading the march – using its video analytic technology combined with technology from dZine, a kiosk placed strategically in a mall can determine a person’s gender, approximate age, and sometimes ethnic background.  Base on the determination, the kiosk’s digital signage can serve an ad that may be relevant to the profile of the viewer.  The gender identification accuracy is about “85 to 90″ percent accurate, but the ability to identify the other characteristics need some improvement.

While this is another step of progress for net-centric marketing, there is still a long way to go.  A 30-something white woman may be there to get a toy for her child, and not care about the lingerie sale at Victoria’s Secret. But how far could this go if a marketer wanted to push this?  Based on a physical shape, could the kiosk serve ads on the local food court, GNC, Jenny Craig, or Gold’s Gym?  Do people want to be publicly served an ad that could betray a need they may want people looking over their shoulders to see?  Could other types of sensors be employed to gather metrics such as cologne worn, pulse, what kind of electronics once could be carrying?

Without other correlatable data such as the type of car the person drove in with or zip code, or some other type of video analtyics such as that used by the security industry, predictive anlaysis or behavioral targeting is not feasible.  Maybe data and capability carried around on an “opted in” cellphone by an individual (Google Latitude, anyone?) could facilitate a much more rewarding engagement if someday integrated with this type of system.  For now, it will probably stir up more controversy than it deserves.

But once again, this is just the beginning.  We will get there..

Krafty and Wal*Smart?

There are two very interesting net-centric marketing developments for in the B2C world that have made the trade press recently.

Kraft iFood Assistant

The Kraft iPhone Assistant is available through iTunes and allows users to view recipes (using Kraft products of course), save favorite recipes, watch a cooking video, create shopping lists, find stores, and even get offers or incentives from participating stores.  All this while seeing ads for Kraft products.  It is currently in the top 100 list of favorite downloaded apps for the Apple iPhone.

Launched last fall, Walmart’s Walmart Smart Network is an IPTV-based network already deployed in 300 stores and will expand to 2,700 stores by the end of next year, with a total of about 27,000 in-aisle screens.  By utilizing response measurement and message optimization technologies, this network will be able to deliver timely, relevant content to shoppers and can be segmented by day of the week, by time of day, by store, and by screen,.  Content about products in the store can be customized for a shopper at the shelf location so they can make a quick decision to purchase.  Response measurement, learning, and message optimization technologies were developed by DS-IQ. [Read more...]

Portability – More than Meets the Eye

In a blog last month entitled “Social Networking : For the Doubting Thomas,” the Marketing Consigliere advised readers to heed the ubiquity of consumer-focused social networking sites like Facebook.  An excellent addition to the discussion is seen in the slides called “Portable Social Graphs – Imagining their Potential” put together recently by Jesse Pickard, May Shi, and Malcolm Ong of Avenue A | Razorfish, and Jesse Stay and Daniel Stern.  Take the time to read each of these slides… they really spell out the promise of social networks for marketers.

Obviously the B2C implications of this are staggering.  But what about B2B?  Can the data mining and predictive analysis  advantages of social networking be extrapolated into the B2B space?  While certain procurement, partnering and acquistion activities of organizations should correctly remain confidential, can’t B2B professionals use social networking tools to make better decisions, relying on their peers for information?  Perhaps professional membership associations could help foster these platforms and provide more value to their constituency.

The Marketing Consigliere would like to to thank Jeremiah Owyang of Forrester Research for making him aware of these great slides through his blog Web Strategy.  He is also also grateful to Jeremiah for inspring him to blog on his own when he mentioned the Marketing Consigliere in his blog in 2007.

The Lighter/Darker Side of Net-Centric Marketing

American Civil Liberties Union

Back in December, The Marketing Consigliere blogged about the “Do Not Track” movement and how it was not good for B2C business (Do Not Resuscitate “Do Not Track” Part I & Part II). While he was critical of the privacy interest groups, he does have a sense of humor and admires their depiction of privacy intrusion in a Flash video he stumbled on the at the ACLU website. It portrays the CRM GUI of an order taker at a place called “Pizza Palace.”

Pizza Palace

With tongue-in-cheek irony, they illustrate the intrusive nickel and diming that a customer may suffer should marketers be allowed to collect business intelligence and perform over-the-top data mining and predictive analysis. He admits he laughed at the scenario.

His thoughts: While it’s technically feasible, it’s further off than they’re trying to make us fear.  The integration of those disparate data points are probably not in even the most enthusiastic of Net-Centric Marketers’ heads. While many would like to have a EMM platform of that capability, the everyday worries of marketing tools such as advertising to even get a single customer still weigh heavily on a marketer’s mind.

While C4ISR Marketing may sound scary when portrayed by the privacy advocates, it is a tool that can be used for the good of both the Marketer and the Customer. Ultimately, the Internet and net-centric world empowers customers too, and as far as I know, in the future there will be still be plenty of pizza joints to choose from….

To underscore his point, he asks you this – would you buy from Pizza Palace after being treated that way?

The Apple of My "I" (As in C4"I"SR)

U.S. Patent Application #20070291710 by Apple Inc. basically is a device that can track where a customer makes purchases, and what was purchased. With this information, loyalty programs can be enhanced for regular customers who may buy certain categories of goods habitually.

Orders could be placed on particular meals, such as a favorite pizza, and the customer could be notified when seating is ready or the pizza is ready for take out.  An apparel retailer could IM or even automatically phone a patron with a synthesized voice recording when a new rack of fashion in that patron’s size has been added to the floor.

Apple, Inc. Logo

This capability puts Apple squarely in the arena as a C4ISR Marketing player and positions them to perhaps take advantage of revenue streams they did not have before.I’ve always admired Apple products – my first laptop was a PowerBook. Now the intelligence the Marketing professionals can gather could be dramatically augmented by this system. Certainly EMM, Data Mining, Predictive Analysis and B2C practices will gain more of a following.

The public relations risk due to the forseeable protest of privacy advocates will be drowned out by the consumers who “get” the benefits of convenience and personalization that will come out of Apple’s pragmatic direction. Let’s hope the US Patent & Trademark Office‘s overworked staff gets this through the clutter.

Do Not Resuscitate Do Not Track

Federal Trade Commission LogoThis is a topic I’ve needed some time to digest mentally before I stuck my proverbial virtual foot in my virtual mouth.

I remember a few weeks ago reading about the FTC hearings on the “Do Not Track” requests coming from some consumer groups. Instantly I thought that the whole behavioral targeting engine would come to a screeching halt. My C4ISR Marketing common sense told me that “”Do Not Track” should be derailed. The Internet and the computing power behind it are inevitably evolving and this process of evolution will result in a higher level of intelligence – especially business intelligence in how we gather, process, extrapolate and act on data. Someday we will look upon our current behavioral targeting as “primitive,” but for now it’s all we have to try to deliver more relevant advertising and other information to an online visitor.

This kind of tracking will become increasingly critical for CRM and data mining, which can bring better economies and products to consumers in the long run. Net-Centric Marketing demands the symbiotic relationship of buyer and seller – the buyer gives information and money, and the seller gives what the buyer wants. If the seller does not have what the buyer wants, the buyer gives the seller more information or the buyer finds another seller who can deliver.

The buyer gives the seller more information by either verbal or written communication, or better yet with his or her actions (which I have been told speak louder than words). Actions tell things that words don’t, and marketers know this. Web analytics tell of certain behaviors that help marketers optimize websites to improve traffic. Behaviors can tell public relations people how their company measures up in many ways.

Kudos to the Interactive Advertising Bureau for taking the right stand against “Do Not Track.” The Marketing Consigliere hopes that they don’t get drowned out by the wailing and gnashing teeth of the so-called “privacy” advocates. Groups like the Electronic Frontier Foundation, which he has known about and even admired for years, seem to be getting shrill in their old age. With the emergence of C4ISR Marketing technologies, he is willing to bet that more people will want to be catered to regarding advertising – they’ll want products more in line with their desires, lifestyles, and behaviors. They won’t want to be mass marketed to like so many of us have been in the past.

Even in light of the privacy faux pas and ado surrounding Facebook, if the Electronic Frontier Foundation wants to truly protect privacy, it should be doing more to help keep both consumers and companies safe from the real threats out there like organized crime and others who try to steal identities, commandeer processing power of privately-owned computers, and use fraud to trick people out of their freedoms and money.